So which do you like better? Polynesian or Japanese?

I'm in a quandary....I'm looking to get a full back tattoo, with arm bands but am having a difficult time deciding which style would work better. Love the simplicity of the Polynesian and the symbolic meanings behind the designs. I also love the color and beautiful flow of the Japanese tats and they too have symbolic meaning.

For the Japanese one I was thinking something along these lines:



I haven't found anything remotely like what I envision for the Polynesian one. I have drawn out my designs, but can't scan them....

So which style do you like better and why....opinions please....

__________________
"Still using all the muscles except the one that matters?"
"If you love me.....you'd rep me RED"

Can you post examples of each?

__________________
Anthony McClellan, NASM-CPT
Team Journal of Typhon & Tony

Here are some examples of the Polynesian style I like:

__________________
"Still using all the muscles except the one that matters?"
"If you love me.....you'd rep me RED"

You know I have nothing but excellent & total respect for you....so please don't be upset with me when I BEG you not to get any tattoo's at all.

Nothing says Double-wide like a tattoo.....

My answer, since you're asking...is neither.

__________________
Don't take life too seriously, but take your health as if your life depended on it. Lycra; it's not just for woman anymore! :P

I have never seen a non-poly with a Polynesian tat...It wouldn't suit - go Asian.

__________________
Bodybuilding is not a sport.

LMAO!!!! I knew there would be a few people who do not particularly like the whole tattoo "stigma" hence, the "neither" option. I can respect that, (I particularly like the "double wide" comment....LOL) but since more people use the term "exotic" to describe what I look like to them, I would probably look more like I need a bone thru my nose, than trailer trash.....lol

In either case, I am already doomed, as I have a tattoo (around my ankle), and have been planing on getting this one for many years. I don't tend to "expose" my body (except to my husband) so it's not something that will likely be seen by anyone but him, and me.

I am fascinated by both the art of Irezumi and the symbolic nature of the Polynesian art and their cultural meanings.....

Thansk for your opinion though...

__________________
"Still using all the muscles except the one that matters?"
"If you love me.....you'd rep me RED"

From seeing your picture, I personally think you look better without any visible tats.

Greatest tattoos on planet earth:









Lulz. But seriously, I think they both have their pros and cons. Whatever you get, you're going to be stuck with for the rest of your life, so I don't think our opinions on them matter.

However, Genki Sudo's eagle tat is inspired by the Nazca Lines in Peru, which seems original and looks awesome.





Update: My files are named "s-h-i-t-t-ytats" and they have been censored. They're funny, too :/

__________________
"It's okay to have idols as a kid, but when you grow up you have to become what you dream about." -Education of a Powerlifter
"Though one were to defeat thousands upon thousands of men in battle, if another were to overcome just one - himself, he is the supreme victor." Dhammpada verse 103

Yeah, I dunno where this sh!t comes from, just pops into my head. I do the obnoxious-jovial thing so you can laugh at it.....t'sall good.

Actually, some ankle tat's are rather cute and for woman I can tolerate some nice accents....but when you've got more tat then skin, it's just (IMO) wrong. But ya know what...it's just an opinion and you know the old saying about that.

If you must.....go Asian. The Poly looks a bit like you travelled back in time, fell asleep and some cave-men went nuts on your back. Ya know, maybe you should try a "Henna" to see if this is really your thing.

I don't mean to sound like a prick (it just happens)...but there's a few older gals in the gym with serious tat's and when you're a bit out-of-shape and in your 50's with an aging body....nothing looks more ridiculous!!!! Ya gotta live for the day but always keep in mind tomorrow........

Ya know...I respect that fact that you're willing to put this up for discussion/opinions. Shine on your crazy diamond.

__________________
Don't take life too seriously, but take your health as if your life depended on it. Lycra; it's not just for woman anymore! :P

Genki actually designed that himself and (apparantly) when he does a lat pulldown, it looks like it's flapping its wings.

__________________
Bodybuilding is not a sport.

I dont know the difference between the styles really, but if you want a tat, get one! Just choose wisely.

Iv still to get my first one, i keep spending up tho! But i no exactly what i want! cant wait

__________________
B T I A IDIOT
I O S N
G M

are you guys kidding,maori ones are the best, im sure NBS will agree haha. Sonnyy bill Williams has awesome ones..

__________________
http://www.aaess.com.au/

well the only part that would be somewhat visible would be the arm bands....

__________________
"Still using all the muscles except the one that matters?"
"If you love me.....you'd rep me RED"

Polynesian, I love polynesian tats.

and now you've seen a non-polynesian w/ a polynesian tat because I have one Streamline.

It's hard to find people in the continental US who do them well. I got mine on Kauai

__________________
I reject your reality and substitute my own -Adam Savage