| » Stats |
Members: 112,998
Threads: 39,689
Posts: 367,978
Top Poster: Karky (9,651) | | Welcome to our newest member, strawberryc | |
If you register for free, you will be able to post threads, vote on polls and lots more. If you have problems with the registration or logging in, please contact the administrator.
 | 
Oct. 19/06, 10:41 AM
| | Registered User | | Join Date: Oct 2006 Location: New York
Posts: 11
| | | critique my diet, please I'm a 27 year old male, around 225 pounds, 6'7" tall, BF probably around 20-25%. I'm trying to get my BF down to 10-15%, at which point, I plan to start bulking. So for the time being, I'm trying to burn as much fat as possible without losing any existing muscle. In the past I've done some boxing and a little weight training, but I'm not experienced with body building. I think I've finally figured out what to do for excercise, but I'm still uncertain about my diet. Here is a typical day:
Meal 1:
big bowl of high protein, high fiber cereal (Kashi Go Lean, it's called) with some protein powder sprinkled on top, and soy milk. 1 hard boiled egg. 2 cups of coffee.
Meal 2:
a big protein shake made with whey protein powder (about 35g protein), a banana, a scoop of yogurt, crushed ice, soy milk, and water.
(this is where I do my excercises for the day)
Meal 3:
tuna made with light mayonaise, with a diced apple mixed in it, over lettuce
Meal 4:
meat and a vegetable, and a piece of whole grain bread
for example: chicken breast with broccoli
Meal 5:
cottage cheese with an avacado mixed in
I'm also drinking a lot of water. I drink water with each meal instead of juice or soda or other forms of beverage (except for that coffee in the morning). And I'm taking a daily multi-vitamin.
Once a week or so, I have some beers but I stick to light beer and I try not to overdo it. I used to be a heavy drinker and that's how I put on most of the weight, so this is a big sacrifice, but I'm getting used to it. I also will have maybe one meal a week where I'm not worrying about nutrition, like pizza with a bunch of meat on it or something like that, but nothing too drastic.
Last edited by j0equ1nn; Oct. 19/06 at 12:27 PM.
| 
Oct. 19/06, 12:36 PM
|  | Junior Member | | Join Date: Aug 2006 Location: Kingston, MASS
Posts: 436
| | How many calories is all that?
Here are a few suggestions about your meals:
Meal 1) I would actually lose the cereal and opt for oatmeal. I find cereal does not hold me over very long.
Meal 2) This is OK. I always like to have whole foods whenever I can, but if you find a protein shake to be easier, then have it
Meal 3) I'd lose the mayo. It's just a waste of calories. BUT, if you find you can easily fit it into your end of the day totals, then have it.
Meal 4 and 5 are ok.
All in all, looks good, but doesn't look like enough calories. Are you strength training? If so, what are you having post workout?
I hope this helps | 
Oct. 19/06, 01:56 PM
|  | Deceptimod | | Join Date: Nov 2004 Location: Nebraska
Posts: 6,134
| | | why all the soy milk? soy isn't the most ideal source for protein...really its just there for the vegans who won't touch any animal products including whey protein.
I think you need more protein in your diet. Keep limiting your cheat meals (pizza, beer) as much as possible.
probably not enough total calories either.
lift heavy weights on compound exercises to keep muscle mass while shedding bodyfat. | 
Oct. 19/06, 06:52 PM
| | Registered User | | Join Date: Oct 2006 Location: New York
Posts: 11
| | Okay then, here's a modification. I added some more high protein foods, including substitution that mayo in the tuna with yogurt (which is actually pretty good).
Meal 1:
big bowl of oatmeal with some protein powder mixed in, made with skim milk. 2 hard boiled eggs. 2 cups of coffee.
Meal 2:
a big protein shake made with whey protein powder (about 35g protein), a banana, a scoop of yogurt, 2 egg whites, crushed ice, and skim milk.
(work out)
post-workout: an 8 oz protein shake (with about 20 grams of protein)
Meal 3:
tuna made with yogurt, with a diced apple mixed in it, over lettuce
Meal 4:
meat and a vegetable, and a piece of whole grain bread
for example: chicken breast with broccoli
Meal 5:
cottage cheese with an avacado and 10 almonds mixed in
After typing that out, I noticed malkore's "This is how I eat" link and signed up for a FitDay account, and entered all the food from those 5 meals into today, to see what it comes out to, and it's
2439 calories
77g fat
203g carbohydrates
239g protein
That seems like too many calories for cutting, but the proportions are right on (40% from protein, 30% carbs, 30% fats).
For my height and weight, shouldn't I be going for more like 2000 calories when cutting?
Yes, I have been doing heavy weights on compound excercises, every other day. Those days, I also do 20 minutes medium cardio. On the days I'm not doing that, I do 20 minutes of HIIT and about an hour of light cardio. | 
Oct. 20/06, 03:39 AM
|  | Junior Member | | Join Date: Aug 2006 Location: Kingston, MASS
Posts: 436
| | | Looks better. My only suggestions:
Post workout keep the protein shake, but get some high GI carbs (malto powder, rice cakes, kids cereal, bagels, etc). Then I would actually switch meal 4 and 5.
As for your calories, to cut I like to do body weight multiplied by 12. This may not be your exact calories, but it's a good place to start. | 
Oct. 20/06, 08:15 AM
|  | Super Moderator | | Join Date: Oct 2005
Posts: 7,364
| | Quote:
Originally Posted by j0equ1nn For my height and weight, shouldn't I be going for more like 2000 calories when cutting? | One formula I use says this, which would put you too low:
BMR 2286.84
Maintenance Cutting Bulking
Sedentary 2744.20 2494.20 3244.20
Light Active 3144.40 2894.40 3644.40
Moderately Active 3544.60 3294.60 4044.60
Very Active 3944.79 3694.79 4444.79
Extra Active 4344.99 4094.99 4844.99
Your tall and have some weight, Im shorter and weigh less, and I was eating 2500-2800 when cutting. | 
Oct. 20/06, 01:43 PM
| | Registered User | | Join Date: Oct 2006 Location: New York
Posts: 11
| | | Hmm, that does help. Thanks a lot. (I also just realized I posted this to the women's forum instead of the men's, woops.)
Just one question, why switch meals 4 and 5? |  | | Thread Tools | Search this Thread | | | | | Display Modes | Rate This Thread | Linear Mode | |
Similar threads to critique my diet, please | | Thread | Thread Starter | Forum | Replies | Last Post | Critique my diet!
Critique my diet!: I've been doing a lot more working keeping my... | Adumb | Body Building | 0 | Sep. 03/08 06:24 PM | critique my diet, please
critique my diet, please: I started a new diet, designed for insulin... | NeuroRN76 | Weight Loss | 18 | Feb. 17/08 05:20 PM | Please Critique my Diet
Please Critique my Diet: Hi Guys,
I am currently at 202 pounds and... | JTM | Nutrition | 2 | Jun. 05/07 02:23 PM | Critique my diet
Critique my diet: Lately, due to the influence of these forums, I... | Xardioso | Nutrition | 9 | Jul. 12/05 06:41 AM | Could someone critique my diet?
Could someone critique my diet?: I'm going to be getting back into weightlifting.... | BestServedCold | Nutrition | 1 | Feb. 21/04 11:04 AM |
Other threads in forum Nutrition | | Thread | Date | Thread Starter | Replies | Last Post | Does this look OK?
Does this look OK?: Hello folks!
My name is Justin, I'm a 25...
| Jun. 10/08 | JDie2033 | 11 | Jun. 10/08 02:41 PM | is this too much?
is this too much?: I am 5ft 114lbs. I want to lose some weight or at...
| Apr. 23/07 | lovesmr777 | 2 | Apr. 25/07 06:12 PM | How to find time to eat right
How to find time to eat right: Hey, I'm trying to bulk up and I cannot seem to...
| Mar. 16/07 | TheTerminator | 3 | Mar. 16/07 06:41 AM | Counting Oil and Confused
Counting Oil and Confused: Hello all. How do you count the calories in...
| Aug. 04/06 | Hogan | 1 | Aug. 05/06 08:24 AM | Diet Lemon Flavored Nestea
Diet Lemon Flavored Nestea: Im cutting down most of the bad stuff im...
| Jan. 15/05 | daytonasurf | 2 | Jan. 26/05 06:12 AM | | » Online Users: 222 | | 4 members and 218 guests | | Cooter, ddj3593, stingo, texasrocker | | Most users ever online was 1,736, Apr. 17/07 at 05:27 PM. | |