| » Stats |
Members: 105,040
Threads: 38,574
Posts: 362,536
Top Poster: Karky (9,553) | | Welcome to our newest member, ox1323 | |
If you register for free, you will be able to post threads, vote on polls and lots more. If you have problems with the registration or logging in, please contact the administrator.
 |
Protein Shake with/without carbs? Other supps.. Post # 1 ( permalink)

Nov. 16/07, 12:49 PM
|  | Newb | | Join Date: Nov 2006
Posts: 78
| | | Protein Shake with/without carbs? Other supps.. I have been lifting for several months on nothing but eating a lot and lifting as heavy as I can. My goal is size gains for the next several more months, just get stronger & bigger, then going to cut for around 2-3 months after that. I have seen nice strength gains, and even nicer size gains, tomorrow I'm going to go out and buy some candy (supplements) I have two questions really:
1. Protein powders, which is best? The one with or without carbs? the one with fat or no fat? should I just search for the one with the highest protein and nothing else? maybe some other good stuff mixed in like bcaa's?
2. What else are important supplements to get? Here is my shopping list:
- 100% Whey Powder, gold standard
- Powder form creatine
- mega men multivitamin
- BCAA's supplement
- Fish Oil supplement
i know for sure I will be purchasing creatine and when powder, what are some good choices for supplements? thanks.
ps. It would be nice to keep as much fat as possible off though. I like doing full body, circuit training 3x week.
Last edited by enz660; Nov. 16/07 at 12:53 PM.
|
Protein Shake with/without carbs? Other supps.. Post # 2 ( permalink)

Nov. 16/07, 01:12 PM
| | Banned | | Join Date: May 2007
Posts: 1,843
| | Quote:
Originally Posted by enz660 I have been lifting for several months on nothing but eating a lot and lifting as heavy as I can. My goal is size gains for the next several more months, just get stronger & bigger, then going to cut for around 2-3 months after that. I have seen nice strength gains, and even nicer size gains, tomorrow I'm going to go out and buy some candy (supplements) I have two questions really: | List the exercises in your circuit training
Do you have any starting and current pics?
1. What was your starting weight when you first started?
2. What is your current weight now?
During your bulk cycle what has your surplus in calories been like? What is your plan on diet while cutting?
Go to this link to learn how to figure your calories for weight gain (bulking) or fat tissue loss (cutting): http://training.fitness.com/nutritio...tml#post237103
We are still working on this link, so it may be moved in the future and become a sticky, and therefore the link may become dead.
Any questions post them here and we will try to answer them. ROCK ON! Quote: |
1. Protein powders, which is best? The one with or without carbs? the one with fat or no fat? should I just search for the one with the highest protein and nothing else? maybe some other good stuff mixed in like bcaa's?
| Dont be overly concerned about the carbs (just be sure to get them in your diet is what I mean).
I am currently using Six Star Whey Powder (without Creatine), and it claims about 25G of protein per serving. Shoot for a ballpark figure of 20 to 30g in the whey powder (somewhere along these lines), and you will be okay. Quote:
2. What else are important supplements to get? Here is my shopping list:
- 100% Whey Powder, gold standard
- Powder form creatine
- mega men multivitamin
- BCAA's supplement
- Fish Oil supplement
| Yes, get the whey powder.
No, do not get any creatine you dont need it. Save your money.
Yes, get a multivitamin
No, do not get any BCAA supplements. Save you money. Yes, get some Fish Oil And Flax Oil Supplements.
The good choices for supplements are in bold. I am not a big fan of supplements--dependent on medical and physical factors. But, the ones in bold will serve your purposes quite well.
Best wishes to you my friend..........
and one more thing
ROCK ON!
KEEP UP THE GREAT PROGRESS!
Chillen
Last edited by Chillen; Nov. 16/07 at 02:02 PM.
|
Protein Shake with/without carbs? Other supps.. Post # 3 ( permalink)

Nov. 17/07, 07:58 AM
|  | Epic Adventurer | | Join Date: Jan 2007
Posts: 1,874
| | Quote:
Originally Posted by Chillen No, do not get any creatine you dont need it. Save your money.
Chillen | I disagree with this. If you are planning on bulking for another three months there is no reason to miss out on the gains that creatine can bring. |
Protein Shake with/without carbs? Other supps.. Post # 4 ( permalink)

Nov. 17/07, 08:03 AM
| | Banned | | Join Date: May 2007
Posts: 1,843
| | Quote:
Originally Posted by realworksuks I disagree with this. If you are planning on bulking for another three months there is no reason to miss out on the gains that creatine can bring. | You are welcome to disagree of course. But, the fact remains, the young man doesnt need it.
He would be better served with applying a diet regime (and meat that already supplies it), then taking the over hyped and over rated creatine. |
Protein Shake with/without carbs? Other supps.. Post # 5 ( permalink)

Nov. 17/07, 08:57 AM
|  | Epic Adventurer | | Join Date: Jan 2007
Posts: 1,874
| | Quote:
Originally Posted by Chillen You are welcome to disagree of course. But, the fact remains, the young man doesnt need it.
He would be better served with applying a diet regime (and meat that already supplies it), then taking the over hyped and over rated creatine. | True, he doesn't NEED creatine. But he doesn't need the fish oils, multivitamins, or even protein powder either. But do they help? Of course.
I think the same is true for creatine. |
Protein Shake with/without carbs? Other supps.. Post # 6 ( permalink)

Nov. 17/07, 09:08 AM
| | Banned | | Join Date: May 2007
Posts: 1,843
| | Quote:
Originally Posted by realworksuks True, he doesn't NEED creatine. But he doesn't need the fish oils, multivitamins, or even protein powder either. But do they help? Of course.
I think the same is true for creatine. | Im not going to debate this issue with ya
Advice I gave is spot on.
Nothing else needs to be added. |
Protein Shake with/without carbs? Other supps.. Post # 7 ( permalink)

Nov. 18/07, 08:08 AM
|  | Deceptimod | | Join Date: Nov 2004 Location: Nebraska
Posts: 5,845
| | | You can do the creatine if you want, but its not some miracle powder. Creatine indirectly helps you add muscle, but if your diet sucks, it won't do diddly.
I think Chillen's point is you need to get on a good routine, good diet, and a consistent rate of progress on your own. its more of a 'performance enhancing' supplement, while the others (fish oil, vitamins, good diet) are just gonna help the body work better, no matter what.
phase 1 - get consistent
phase 2 - add creatine if you feel the need...honestly at age 19, I'd save all the money you can for college, a safe vehicle, and house planning. |
Protein Shake with/without carbs? Other supps.. Post # 8 ( permalink)

Nov. 18/07, 11:21 AM
| | Banned | | Join Date: May 2007
Posts: 1,843
| | Yep, Malkore.........that hit it square on the point...... |
Protein Shake with/without carbs? Other supps.. Post # 9 ( permalink)

Nov. 18/07, 11:43 AM
| | Junior Member | | Join Date: Sep 2007 Location: Iowa
Posts: 107
| | | I'd just chime in on the issue of the EFA supplements...
whether you choose flax oil or fish oil (or both), go for the liquid versions rather than capsules. In order to get the dose that does any good, you need many, many capsules per day, as opposed to a tablespoon of the direct form.
Might also want to look into ground flaxseed as well. 3 tbsp. of ground seed is roughly equivalent to 1 tbsp. oil, and you get a great shot of lignens and fiber at the same time.
If you are squeamish about the fish oil, I can tell you I use an orange flavored cod liver oil, and mix it with orange (sugar free) metamucil, and it has absolutely no fishy taste whatsoever.
Also, I don't do a multivitamin, but rather put together my own ****tail of "separates". I've never really felt that 1 pill can give the dosage of many important vits/mins that do much good. Just like anything can be toxic if the dosage is high enough, it goes the other way as well. Some components are better taken with food, especially some fat, while other things I take are better at bedtime, for me that's high dose niacin for example. |  | | Thread Tools | Search this Thread | | | | | Display Modes | Rate This Thread | Linear Mode | |
Similar threads to Protein Shake with/without carbs? Other supps.. | | Thread | Thread Starter | Forum | Replies | Last Post | When to eat carbs and protein?
When to eat carbs and protein?: :action13: I have been told two different ways on... | Brandibeth | Nutrition | 6 | Mar. 25/09 09:51 AM | Difference between: protein shake, weight gain supp. and meal replacement shake?
Difference between: protein shake, weight gain supp. and meal replacement shake?: Basically what is in the title
Thanks! | betsie2k | Weight Training | 5 | Jan. 27/07 04:42 AM | fat/protein/carbs, wtf
fat/protein/carbs, wtf: alright, i'm male, 6'1", 180lbs, 16% fat. i'd... | awesomeame | Nutrition | 2 | Apr. 30/06 05:13 PM | Protein shake good for 500-600 calories worth per shake
Protein shake good for 500-600 calories worth per shake: I am currently on a 2,500 a day caloric intake,... | Howieau | Supplements | 5 | Apr. 03/06 09:10 PM | Protein shake w/ low carbs for cutting?
Protein shake w/ low carbs for cutting?: I was going to get Biotest Surge but its been... | JimBo123 | Weight Training | 1 | Jul. 15/04 03:34 AM |
Other threads in forum Supplements | | Thread | Date | Thread Starter | Replies | Last Post | How good in GNC?
How good in GNC?: since I have started to work on my health, I have...
| Jul. 25/08 | Akira5284 | 19 | Sep. 06/08 08:34 AM | supplements...
supplements...: Hey guys. Ok look i was born 3.5 months premature...
| Nov. 24/05 | briz | 3 | Nov. 27/05 01:13 AM | Are protein supplements worth the money?
Are protein supplements worth the money?: I'm living in a university dorm this year, and...
| Nov. 02/04 | Bob | 7 | Jan. 18/05 06:39 AM | No2/ NoX2
No2/ NoX2: I recently bought some NoX2, sounds good, havn't...
| Dec. 19/04 | SlagOps | 2 | Dec. 22/04 06:48 PM | Flax Seed Oil capsules
Flax Seed Oil capsules: What does everyone think about taking flax seed...
| Mar. 31/04 | jehn | 12 | Apr. 10/04 05:10 PM | | » Online Users: 235 | | 4 members and 231 guests | | mruthe00, ox1323, p.wilson14, tic | | Most users ever online was 1,736, Apr. 17/07 at 06:27 PM. | |