| » Stats |
Members: 104,997
Threads: 38,572
Posts: 362,532
Top Poster: Karky (9,553) | | Welcome to our newest member, totti | |
If you register for free, you will be able to post threads, vote on polls and lots more. If you have problems with the registration or logging in, please contact the administrator.
 | 
Dec. 20/07, 01:07 AM
|  | Verge of Overtraining | | Join Date: May 2007 Location: Australia
Posts: 1,236
| | | No cardio for muscle growth So yeah i like never run....ever....All i do is a 15-20 min walk at normal pace after my workouts. Should i be doing intense cardio at all because i am pretty skinny already and any cardio is just gonna make my metabolism even faster wont it ? | 
Dec. 20/07, 01:19 AM
|  | Verge of Overtraining | | Join Date: Oct 2005 Location: Brisbane, Australia
Posts: 1,393
| | | Uh yeah, but if you wanna live past 50, i suggest you do some cardio. | 
Dec. 20/07, 02:17 AM
| | Junior Member | | Join Date: Apr 2006 Location: Dublin, Ireland
Posts: 212
| | | ye just eat more to compensate for the extra calories burned | 
Dec. 20/07, 04:04 AM
|  | Third Set | | Join Date: Nov 2007
Posts: 635
| | Quote:
Originally Posted by SmithMachine So yeah i like never run....ever....All i do is a 15-20 min walk at normal pace after my workouts. Should i be doing intense cardio at all because i am pretty skinny already and any cardio is just gonna make my metabolism even faster wont it ? | I've seen that on some strongman site and I presume that that is why some of the hardcore guys never do warm-up or any cardio at all. I disagree with that but that is not probably what you want to hear. | 
Dec. 20/07, 04:16 AM
|  | Former member of VulgarityGang | | Join Date: Dec 2005 Location: had to quit when he became a mod
Posts: 9,553
| | | when you're a hardcore lifter, like a competitive strongman, oly lifter or powerlifter, you probably don't want to do much running. The thing is, when you run and get tired, some of your body's fast fibers will have to do slow fiber jobs, making you less "fast twitch" in the long run. What has been recommended by many is to just walk.. 2-3 times a day, walk for 10-15 min. You will use only slow twitch and you will get some energy work in. If you're a competitive lifter, your goal is not to to be able to run for long distances.. the walking will be enough to keep you healthy.
But that's really nothing to worry about for a gym rat or weekend warrior. If you want to do some cardio, just make sure you eat enough. | 
Dec. 20/07, 04:36 AM
| | Needs to Deload | | Join Date: Apr 2007 Location: Toronto
Posts: 1,658
| | Quote:
Originally Posted by SmithMachine So yeah i like never run....ever....All i do is a 15-20 min walk at normal pace after my workouts. Should i be doing intense cardio at all because i am pretty skinny already and any cardio is just gonna make my metabolism even faster wont it ? | Unless one of your specific goals is to improve your overall cardiovascular fitness ( i.e VO2 Max, lactate threshold ) or you want to use " intense cardio " as part of an overall effort to shred fat, there's no reason / need you have to do " intense cardio ".
That said, after weight training, you may want to simply do use walking ( as you've been doing ) or some other form of light cardio to help flush out any lactic acid from your muscles, or you can also use some some light cardio as a warm up before weight training. | 
Dec. 20/07, 05:07 AM
|  | Wearing a Cool Hat | | Join Date: Dec 2006 Location: Lexington, SC
Posts: 1,580
| | Quote: |
Should i be doing intense cardio at all because i am pretty skinny already and any cardio is just gonna make my metabolism even faster wont it ?
| It is not necessary to do cardio. There are many ways to get into shape, cardio is not the only thing. Quote: |
Uh yeah, but if you wanna live past 50, i suggest you do some cardio.
| Quote: |
I've seen that on some strongman site and I presume that that is why some of the hardcore guys never do warm-up or any cardio at all.
| Good strongmen are in good shape. You have to be in shape to be competitive. The conditioning is different. Here are some things we do to stay conditioned.
Stone lifts followed by sprints.
2-5 minute round robins lifting 100+ lbs.
Kettle Bell circuits.
Sled dragging.
Dumbbell circuits.
You get in shape with this type of training, and it is more beneficial for someone whose goal is strength and size. As opposed to walking on a treadmill.
Off Topic. The reason for no warm-up. When you go to a contest you can lift the implements a couple times if you like. (the smallest of which is usually close to 300lbs) Then they tell you. "There is a tent, we will call your name when you are up."
So a strongmen has to be ready to compete with little warm-up. | 
Dec. 20/07, 06:04 AM
|  | I love me some Mreik | | Join Date: Feb 2005 Location: Behind Mreik, waxing his back
Posts: 5,942
| | | Smith, keep in mind that you don't have to do intense cardio but some is good for cardiovascular health. | 
Dec. 20/07, 06:20 AM
|  | Third Set | | Join Date: Nov 2007
Posts: 635
| | Quote:
Originally Posted by goergen1 Off Topic. The reason for no warm-up. When you go to a contest you can lift the implements a couple times if you like. (the smallest of which is usually close to 300lbs) Then they tell you. "There is a tent, we will call your name when you are up."
So a strongmen has to be ready to compete with little warm-up. | Warm up/stretching is pretty much standard among pro boxers and martial arts. There is no medical justification not to do so. | 
Dec. 20/07, 06:31 AM
| | Joe Blow | | Join Date: Dec 2007 Location: Denver, Colorado
Posts: 3
| | | Do some cardio, as others have said, it does not have to be intense cardio. You will continue making strength and size gains. When I finally started incoporating regular cardio into my training (not until my early 30's; talk about wasted years) I found that I was actually getting stronger (and feeling better).
Most people I've seen in the gym over the years don't do the type of strength-training that is going to result in any real cardio benefits. They rest several minutes between sets, do minimal reps, push as much weight as possible, etc. No cardio benefits to this.
My priorities have changed as I've gotten older. So what if a guy has a 50 inch chest and can bench 400 or 500 lbs? If he can't go up two flights of stairs without becoming out of breath, if he can't run two miles without having a stroke, then the guy is in very poor shape. I'd rather bench 300 and be able to run a marathon, or run up a mountain, than bench 500, and be unable to run around a block.
Anyway, just my two cents. | 
Dec. 20/07, 07:38 AM
|  | Verge of Overtraining | | Join Date: Oct 2005 Location: Brisbane, Australia
Posts: 1,393
| | | Cheers georgie. | 
Dec. 20/07, 08:06 AM
| | Banned | | Join Date: May 2007
Posts: 1,843
| | One "could" just sit on the butt, adjust calories under maintenance, and "lose tissue weight"--speaking hypothetically of course. This isnt what I would reccommend (lol).
No cardio isnt required to lose fat tissue, and for "most average persons" in the gym, doing cardio "in general" will have a minimal impact on muscle growth, in my humble opinion.
There are many ways to warm up "without" cardio and there are proper ways to warm up "with" light and very short cardio.
However, cardio can play a rather critical role in a persons goal, dependent what that goal is.
(Personally, I respond rather strong to it. I dont even like it, but I do it. One has to have some "controlled obessession" that works for them independent of other opinions on this obssession and work with things they dont like and perform the task if it favors their goal task) For example, if a persons goal is to lose fat tissue weight as the "primary goal", and they have just been doing a weight training routine for--a time--and deficit dieting and no cardio. One could add in cardio as an extra calorie burner and if intensity and duration (etc) are correct, could assist in additional fat loss. This small change could "spark" the body to give up some more fat tissue. This is just one example, there are other ways without cardio as well.
Cardio has its place dependent upon the person and goals they want to achieve. However, I think we could all agree that its good for the heart among other fitness and health benefits.
Best wishes to you!
Chillen
Last edited by Chillen; Dec. 20/07 at 08:58 AM.
|  | | Thread Tools | Search this Thread | | | | | Display Modes | Rate This Thread | Linear Mode | |
Similar threads to No cardio for muscle growth | | Thread | Thread Starter | Forum | Replies | Last Post | Does too much cardio impact muscle growth???
Does too much cardio impact muscle growth???: I’m 25 years old, 6’1” and 180lbs. I've been... | csheldo1 | Body Building | 5 | Aug. 07/08 02:18 PM | getting muscle growth & tone from mainly cardio?
getting muscle growth & tone from mainly cardio?: hello there.
SO, last year or so i did a... | ostego | Young Athlete Development | 9 | Jul. 15/08 04:44 PM | Muscle growth?
Muscle growth?: Bare with me and my terrible writing :o
So... | SmithMachine | Weight Training | 30 | Dec. 03/07 08:43 PM | Muscle Growth
Muscle Growth: How is it that these guys I see lifting less than... | EpheMeroN | Weight Training | 17 | Jun. 07/04 02:52 PM | muscle Growth....
muscle Growth....: I was just wonder whats a average/repectable time... | xplosiv3 | Weight Training | 3 | Apr. 21/04 03:55 AM |
More threads of SmithMachine | | Thread | Date | Forum | Replies | Last Post | Cloverfield
Cloverfield: Read a review on it and seen some adds and it...
| Jan. 15/08 | Open Talk | 50 | Jan. 21/08 10:14 AM | Best street party ever.
Best street party ever.: YouTube - Best Street Party Ever - Parents Yet To...
| Jan. 18/08 | Open Talk | 21 | Jan. 20/08 02:30 AM | Sweting for pimples.
Sweting for pimples.: Is it true that sweating cleans the pores in your...
| Jan. 13/08 | Wellness | 10 | Jan. 18/08 04:21 AM | supplement list.
supplement list.: Supplements i have.
1: protien powder= 2-4...
| Jan. 16/08 | Supplements | 1 | Jan. 17/08 03:50 AM | Time for celltech hardcore!?
Time for celltech hardcore!?: So i am about to buy some more creatine but this...
| Jan. 10/08 | Supplements | 19 | Jan. 15/08 08:48 PM |
Other threads in forum Weight Training | | Thread | Date | Thread Starter | Replies | Last Post | back and neck :(
back and neck :(: hi, ive noticed lower back pain which goes down...
| Aug. 27/06 | gunit | 6 | Aug. 28/06 07:57 AM | Creatine?
Creatine?: Hey, I'm a 16 year old male, and I've been...
| Jul. 08/06 | Mico | 26 | Jul. 11/06 09:37 AM | Which is the best fat burning exercise?
Which is the best fat burning exercise?: I've been going to the gym for absolutely ages...
| Sep. 10/05 | xxxpinkladyxxx | 7 | Sep. 21/05 11:28 AM | Is creatine for me?
Is creatine for me?: I have done my research, understand how creatine...
| Jan. 11/05 | Novabound08 | 5 | Jan. 12/05 11:07 PM | newbie question about pushups
newbie question about pushups: about 2+ days ago i did about 50 pushups or so,...
| Jan. 14/04 | GrimReaper | 1 | Jan. 14/04 10:34 PM | | » Online Users: 248 | | 5 members and 243 guests | | gelab, hatcht9x, Karky, totti, Woopydalan | | Most users ever online was 1,736, Apr. 17/07 at 06:27 PM. | |