If you register for free, you will be able to post threads, vote on polls and lots more. If you have problems with the registration or logging in, please contact the administrator.
Too Much Time Between Lifting? Post #1 (permalink)
May. 15/08, 09:48 AM
jayawhite
Warming Up
Join Date: Mar 2008
Posts: 45
Too Much Time Between Lifting?
Can having too much time between lifting be detrimental to your results? I have a set of 10 exercises I used to do all in one workout period. I worked out M, W, and F, because I know you're supposed to have time to recuperate between workouts. However, it was a long workout, so I split it into two workouts. I've been lifting every other day, so I do five of the exercises one day, skip a day do the other five exercises, skip a day, and repeat. This means there are three days between workouts of the same set of exercises.
I wouldn't mind lifting every day, because each workout is now shorter. However, would this be bad, because I wouldn't be allowing enough time between workouts? Granted, each of the ten exercises works different muscles, but I'm sure there is some overlap in some of them.
Am I losing any muscle-building/fat burning gains by lifting every other day, which means there are three days between each exercise group? For example: M: group 1, W: group 2, F: group 1, Sun: group 2, etc. That means there are three days (T, W, and Th) between the exercises I do in group 1.
Here are the exercises I do:
Group 1: bench press, lunges (w/ dumbbells), back press, standing calf raises, one-arm dumbbell rows.
Group 2: upright rows, squats (w/ dumbbells), triceps dips, lying leg curl, curls (biceps).
Thanks in advance for you advice/thoughts on this.
Too Much Time Between Lifting? Post #2 (permalink)
May. 15/08, 09:52 AM
Typhon
PR team needed
Join Date: Jul 2006
Posts: 6,841
Quote:
Originally Posted by jayawhite
Here are the exercises I do:
Group 1: bench press, lunges (w/ dumbbells), back press, standing calf raises, one-arm dumbbell rows.
Group 2: upright rows, squats (w/ dumbbells), triceps dips, lying leg curl, curls (biceps).
Why not swap the one armed rows from group 1 with the triceps dips from group 2? That way you'd have more of a push/pull split which you can do on back-to-back days. Either that or try an upper/lower split
Last edited by Typhon; May. 15/08 at 12:35 PM.
Too Much Time Between Lifting? Post #3 (permalink)
May. 15/08, 10:01 AM
jayawhite
Warming Up
Join Date: Mar 2008
Posts: 45
Should have included goals...
If this helps--my goals are to lose body fat. The weight lifting is more of a fat-burning strategy than a "body-building" one. I'm currently on a daily 20% calorie deficit and also doing steady-state cardio and HIIT.
Too Much Time Between Lifting? Post #4 (permalink)
May. 15/08, 01:27 PM
jayawhite
Warming Up
Join Date: Mar 2008
Posts: 45
Quote:
Originally Posted by CCR
Why not swap the one armed rows from group 1 with the triceps dips from group 2? That way you'd have more of a push/pull split which you can do on back-to-back days. Either that or try an upper/lower split
So, if I switched the one armed rows with the triceps, it would be okay to do something like: Mon: group 1; Tues: group 2; Wed: group 1; Thurs: group 2; Fri., Sat., Sun: rest? If so, I think I'll try that. And then, after a while, I think I'll try the upper/lower split--I did a little reading on that.
Thanks!
Too Much Time Between Lifting? Post #5 (permalink)
May. 16/08, 01:03 AM
Typhon
PR team needed
Join Date: Jul 2006
Posts: 6,841
I'd have thought that would be OK but If you're going to be training 4 days a week why not train M,T,T,F and have Wednesday off for a little extra recovery time?
Too Much Time Between Lifting? Post #6 (permalink)
May. 16/08, 10:56 AM
iocinneide
In Orientation
Join Date: Mar 2006
Location: Hamilton, Ohio
Posts: 11
I agree with CCR on the split but, if you have just started with the program, you may even want to rotate your exercises over a period of six days (three of each split every week). Plus, if you are doing higher reps for fat burning (12+), you will have less need for recovery time.